The Main Street Economic Effect: 10 Reasons why This Recession will feel like a Minor Depression.

The investing world is full of cryptic words.  Credit default swaps.  Seasonal adjustments.  Collateralized debt obligations.  But for the average American they are interested in how the economic crisis will impact them on a personal level.  How does the actions of Wall Street impact their daily lives.

It is my belief that by the end of next year, most people will feel this recession as an economic depression.  Many have argued that this housing bubble only started recently but I have argued that this foundation started way back in 1979. We hear a lot of these words being thrown around with little data to back up any predictions.  So first, let us define what we will measure as a depression.  For our rubric, we will use the U-6 broad measure of unemployment which is a wider and broader measure of the employment picture.  First let us look at the current regular measure of unemployment versus the U-6:

U-3 employment

U-6 employment

I was encourage to see that the New York Times reported this nuance in one of their latest articles.  The difference between 6.7% and 12.5% is large.  So what does U-6 include that U-3 doesn’t?

(a)  Marginally attached workers who currently are neither working nor looking for work but indicate that they want and are available for a job and have looked for work sometime in the past.

(b)  Persons employed part-time for economic reasons but want full-time work.

(c)  Discouraged works who are a subset of marginally attached.  These folks have essentially given up looking for work because of the job market.

I think most of us would venture to say those are groups to consider as unemployed.  So our benchmark for depression level is 19% via U-6. During the Great Depression the rate hovered around this rate for many years:

Great Depression unemployment rate

And it is very possible we will see 19% next year because the rate is now accelerating.  Just take a look how quickly the U-6 measure jumped up in one year:

A-12 u-6 employment

The rate has jumped from 8.4% to 12.5% in one year, an increase of 48%.  If we use only this rate and apply it to next year, the rate by next November will be 18.6% and we believe the rate will only accelerate.  Why?  If you look at the early part of the year, job losses started out slowly and then picked up speed toward the end:


Take a look at the above chart.  For the first 8 months of the year 655,000 jobs were lost.  In the last 3 months alone over 1.2 million jobs have been lost.  This is usually what happens with recessions. Even if you take a look at the mild recession in 2001 you will see how many consecutive months we had job losses and how quickly they escalated and stayed high.

So for our measure, we will say that 19% via the U-6 measure will qualify as a minor depression.  Let us now look at the 10 reasons why this recession will turn into a minor depression:

Reason #1 – Retail Sales

Retail sales chart

The life blood of our economy is consumption.  GDP estimates put consumption at over 70% of our fuel running our economy.  That is why all eyes are on the shopping malls during this holiday season (or people trying to get lucky on bingo).  It is one last hurrah before reality sets in during 2009.  Early indicators are not looking good.  Even if we look at the recent media layoffs and the Tribune Co. bankruptcy, much of this is due to imploding advertising revenues.  Why have ad revenues dropped? Because companies are cutting back their marketing budgets.  Why?  Because they are losing revenue.  Why?  Because people are not spending.  It is a rather vicious circle that doesn’t show signs of improvement.  Much of our employment sector is predicated on high consumption so this is a recipe for further job losses.

Reason #2 – Motor Vehicle Sales

motor vehicle sales

It should be rather apparent that auto sales are important to the United States.  That is why the above chart is so startling.  Across the board auto sales are falling.  People bought cars on financing and the credit markets are frozen.  It isn’t like people had the money to buy a car especially if you were making $46,000 a year like 50% of the country.  Plus, many people have bought new cars that simply last longer with better technology.  It then becomes a want and not a need to buy or lease a new car.  Even if the big 3 get some help sales are still going to continue to drop and even with a helping hand, thousands will be laid off.  The peak buying cycle is simply gone.

Reason #3 – Consumer Sentiment

Consumer sentiment

A certain part of the market is driven by consumer sentiment.  I would argue that the reality of the economy is driving consumer sentiment instead of a psychological belief.  However, sentiment does play a major role.  If you are worried about losing your job you probably won’t buy a new home or car until things settle down.  Well things won’t settle down until people start buying.  You can see the Catch-22 here.  Yet our massive debt load has caused globally for $50 trillion in wealth to be destroyed in the matter of one year.  That will do a number on your sentiment.  Expect consumer sentiment to stay low for the near future thus fueling more cautious spending behavior.

Reason #4 – Saving More

Personal saving rate

People in tough economic times save money or at least try to.  This is no exception.  It isn’t like people are saving tons of money but keep in mind a dollar you save is a dollar you don’t spend.  It was stunning that in 2005 we had a radically low savings rate that was under zero.  We were borrowing to pay for future goods and services.  That is now over.  Americans will be more cautious and many will start saving more simply by force.  If you want something you may need to save a few months in a bank account.  That is also why this number is up a bit.

Reason #5 – Hours Worked

Hours worked

As you can see from the above chart the hours worked has fallen significantly.  Well you need money to spend.  If you are not working as much, you have less money to spend thus fueling the above contraction in retail sales even further.  This will only accelerate since we are deleveraging the current economy from the finance, insurance, and real estate sectors.

Reason #6 – Household Debt Burden

household debt burden

It is amazing that after all the debt destruction and deflation, that the household debt burden is still at record highs.  This will only add to the lack of spending.  Keep in mind we have a race to the bottom here.  For example, a mortgage defaults and the balance is no longer a viable indicator of the value of the home.  It sells for $100,000 less.  That money was destroyed.  Yet for the borrower that just lost the home, they have lost an asset from their balance sheet.  Their debt burden may have gone away in this sense but the burden was shifted to the lender.  Either way, we’ll be seeing a lot of this deleveraging in the next few months.

It is expected that 2009 will have the highest number of foreclosures in history and that says a lot given that 2008 will see over 3,000,000 foreclosure filings nationwide.

Reason #7 – Short-term Interest Rates

short term interest rates

There is a global panic.  The above chart shows this.  Short-term treasuries are returning a near zero percent rate.  You may ask why would anyone put their money into a security with such a low return.  Simple.  Panic and security.  That is what the interest rate markets tell us.  The stock market is all over the map but as I have said in detail, market volatility is sign of a sick and desperate market, not a sign of a healthy and vibrant economy.  So until we see the credit markets improving, we can rest assured that people will be hoarding money and not lending it out.

Reason #8 – Double Stock Bubbles

stock market bubble

We went from the technology bubble right into the real estate bubble.  2 decades and 2 bubbles.  I’m not sure if the global financial system has it in itself to go for a third.  There is talks about certain industries like green energy seeing a bubble but the incentive may be lost for many now that oil is around $40 a barrel.  We need it for other reasons but just like the 1970s oil crisis, once the scare is gone people go back to their daily routine.  The stock markets are still off and have still seen $32 trillion in global wealth disappear.  Even after this recent run-up, they are still down for the year significantly.

Reason #9 – Account Balance

Account balance

No country can go on forever spending more than it makes.  We have been doing that since 1994.  We now have a trade imbalance of over $733 billion.  That is not good.  No dominant society will stay that way for the long-term.  We send our treasuries abroad and we consume locally.  That makes our trading partners wealthier while we get instant gratification.

And here is the irony.  We as a nation need to correct this for long-term sustainability or we are doomed.  Yet if we do address this by cutting back, retail will get hammered and our economy will suffer in the short-term.  That is why we are at the tipping point where hard decisions will need to be made.

Reason #10 – Commodities Falling

commodity bubble

Commodity prices have been in a near free fall.  Oil is now trading at near $40 a barrel when just a few months ago it was at $147 a barrel. This has added a few hundred dollars each month into the wallets of most Americans.  This would be interpreted as good in most circumstances but the only reasons we are seeing a crash in commodities is because of demand destruction and deleveraging.  Americans are going to need every penny that goes back into their wallets.  And keep in mind globally many countries rely on oil for revenues and many estimates state that $50 a barrel is the breakeven point for many countries.  In addition domestically, many producers need the higher price to be viable so if it stays here for awhile, expect job losses in these industries.

That is the current predicament.  It is rather apparent after looking at the above 10 reasons that we will likely see U-6 unemployment hit 19% by the end of 2009.  Fortunately we have more safety nets than during the Great Depression but to expect this to be a walk in the park is naïve.  We are in a serious situation and things will only get tougher in the short run.

RSSIf you enjoyed this post click here to subscribe to a complete feed and stay up to date with today’s challenging market!

TAGS: , , , , , ,

11 Comments on this post


  1. Penny K said:

    It’s going to be called the Greater Depression, and it’s not just going to feel like one, it’s going to be one, and in fact is in the early stages.
    We have killed the goose that laid the golden eggs with too much greed and speculation/leveraging. It can only be undone by collapsing in on itself to whatever is fundamental, and rebuild from there.

    I’ve been dreaming of this time since almost 3 (1947). Lines of hungry people, heard “banks stopped lending money because they needed it for themselves and small businesses (like my dad’s) couldn’t get the money they needed to borrow to keep their businesses open”. That was in a dream of 1950 right after my Dad lost his business. Sound familiar…same time frame I dreamed of Depression in 2009…

    I’ll bet you think we are going to have a real (not small) depression, but you are hedging your public image…

    December 10th, 2008 at 7:34 am
  2. Curt said:

    Wow. That is quit a report you put together. I agree, the recession is going to be long and deep. Brace yourself for the next leg down in the market next year.

    December 11th, 2008 at 9:43 am
  3. georgie pat. tonn said:

    sam’s jobs 1941-45: $20/month. travel overseas
    eat free k- rations. join C C C .
    W P A
    N R A
    F D R
    W W 2 = recovery

    December 11th, 2008 at 12:27 pm
  4. zack said:

    wwwooooooowwww that`s scary , i do not know what to say , but i`m really scared , and i don`t want to hear or read all of that , but i ended up reading it all from a to z , now i didn`t save any money , and and i just lost my job , i was looking for a job everywhere but i did not find any , and i do not know what to do . but the only thing that i want to hear is something good about the economy .
    but what i only hear is scary stuff everybody scares everybody, the media scares the citizens …..etc . hopefully we all can survive during this time if not it will be like a jungle .

    December 21st, 2008 at 1:22 pm
  5. adebayo onanuga said:

    This article offers so much insight, though a frightening one. I believe that the recession plaguing the world will not be overcome so easily, with stories of economic gloom and doom all over the world. The losers are the philosophers of the free economy, a doctrine that has now been discredited like communism, at a great expense and great pain to the entire humanity.

    Governments all over the world need to wake up to their responsibility. Let them all go back to the basics by regulating the markets and protecting the weak and the poor via welfare programmes.

    December 22nd, 2008 at 2:01 pm
  6. Andy said:

    For all of the above reasons i have to agree.

    By January 08 Banks were declaring billions of write downs based on property valuations at the time, these write downs sent the banks in to melt down while the valuations are still dropping and the fed has shot it’s big guns already.

    We are now in the declining spiral where more unemployment means less productivity, more bsuinesses going under and even more jobless.

    This will doubtlessly lead to more bank writedowns and more tighening of the credit markets.

    I’m normally an optimistic person, but in this case i think the writing is on the wall.

    If you read about the “expert” views of the great depression you’ll see that many thought it was almost over when in fact it ran for another five years,

    January 2nd, 2009 at 2:32 pm
  7. Surviving A Recession said:

    I think you are absolutely right. This is a fantastic article. I really learned a lot. One thing i found interesting is the change in measuring unemployment. It almost seems as if we are just simply fooling ourselves by using the U3 statistics instead of the U6 statistics.

    i don’t understand why watch dog groups don’t point this kind of stuff out. It may be that many americans just don’t care until it hits their bottom line.

    January 9th, 2009 at 9:37 am
  8. Robert said:

    I have said for ten years they wanted to cause this
    and Canada is not exempt

    as long as you let everyone have their rights

    go along with the gay and lesbian movement

    dont talk about religion or god

    and dont forget that we should be killing all people that make less than fifty thousand dollars a year

    I am just a loser that raised four children alone for fourteen years

    the UN rights of the child says I have no rights

    so the children should be taken from me and be taught that gay is OK
    and that the world wants all of us to be slaves
    and the elite to be rich

    and war whats it good for? well thats easy
    POPULATION REDUCTION didnt you all know that the monument
    in georgia in the states simply says the MASONS WANT THE WORLD POPULATION AT FIVE HUNDRED MILLION

    of course a hundred million of those have to be twenty year old woman with really nice asses that like to service men that are fifty or older for THE MONEY AND ALL THE PROPERTY THEY WILL OWN
    and in the NEW WORLD order soon it will be ok for brothers and sisters to mate too as long as they LOVE EACH OTHER

    god bless us WILL SOMEONE PLEASE send the NUKES

    January 17th, 2009 at 4:51 pm
  9. DailyCashSaver said:

    Well you forget that Unemployment isnt a really indicator. Look this way if you take 10 people 3 of them lose jobs 5 of them are still working full time and 2 of them are working half their hours they were working before what is the unemployment rate? 30% right? Wrong it should be 40% but they dont equvilate people who are working less then before. Also The Federal Reserve Controls the Flow of money thus the cause of the Recession not the private sector. Mean this Abolish the FED! Want More Common sense like this go to

    August 25th, 2009 at 5:51 pm
  10. belldirect said:

    It is true that the recession is long and deep. According to analysts, we are still in the second phase and would be entering the third phase of the recession soon (soon is still undefined). Many ask whether the economy will go through worst before it gets better however, panicking will not help either. Let us not forget that major losses as well as gains happen during a recession. Amidst the crisis, stock market has still perks to offer. We just need to exert an effort to educate ourselves to invest. All industries are offering low interest rates i.e in loans, mortgages and others. Though this act is to leverage loss, as consumers these offers are favorable to us. In these times what we need is a proper balance of spending and saving, nothing more nothing less. I am not an expert and could be wrong but it is the easiest way for us to recover.

    August 31st, 2009 at 10:14 pm
  11. itsoke said:

    here is my theory world war 2 force us government to print huge amount of money ,the raised during the war boost productivity instantly and drastically … but huge increase of money quantity do not spur inflation thanks to huge demand of us goods from destroyed-by-war europe . Marshal plan help both europe and american economy to recover.

    September 4th, 2009 at 2:41 am


Subscribe Form

Subscribe to Blog

My Budget 360

Enter your email address to receive updates from My Budget 360:

100% Private & Spam Free.


Subscribe in a reader


Popular – All Time

  • 1. How much does the Average American Make? Breaking Down the U.S. Household Income Numbers.
  • 2. Top 1 Percent Control 42 Percent of Financial Wealth in the U.S. – How Average Americans are Lured into Debt Servitude by Promises of Mega Wealth.
  • 3. Is college worth the money and debt? The cost of college has increased by 11x since 1980 while inflation overall has increased by 3x. Diluting education with for-profits. and saddling millions with debt.
  • 4. The Perfect $46,000 Budget: Learning to Live in California for Under $50,000.
  • 5. Family Budget: How to go Broke on $100,000 a year. Why the Middle Class has a hard time Living in Expensive Urban Areas.
  • 6. Lining up at Midnight at Wal-Mart to buy Food is part of the new Recovery. Banks offering Mattress Interest Rates. The Invisible Recovery Outside of Wall Street.
  • 7. You Cannot Afford a $350,000 Home with a $75,000 Household Income!
  • 8. Crisis of generations – younger Americans moving back home in large numbers. Student loan default rates surging largely due to for-profit college expansion.
  • 9. The next massive debt bubble to crush the economy – 10 charts examining the upcoming implosion of the student loan market. $1 trillion in student loans and defaults sharply increasing.
  • 10. Welcome to the new model of retirement. No retirement. In 1983 over 60 percent of American workers had some kind of defined-benefit plan. Today less than 20 percent have access to a plan and the majority of retired Americans largely rely on Social Security as their de facto retirement plan.
  • Categories