Is the stock market a sham for the middle class? Retail investors expected to pull out $475 billion in funds. Volatility index under pricing real risks.
- 3 Comment
The stock market is largely a source of entertainment or awe for most Americans instead of being a true source of wealth. In the United States roughly 42 percent of all financial wealth is aggregated with one percent of the population. One third of Americans have no savings at all so for this group, the stock market does not even enter the equation. Yet the stock market itself is now inching closer to record levels. Even volatility is abnormally low given that we barely avoided the fiscal cliff and are dealing with debt ceiling challenges once again. The stock market would signify that the American economy is doing fantastic. In reality, many people are still struggling and many organizations used the recession as a period to cut jobs and slash costs. The economy is still short four million jobs from the peak reached a few years ago yet here we are, with the stock market up over 100+ percent from the March 2009 lows. Is the stock market a sham for the middle class?
Stock market and jobs
One of the more convincing pieces of evidence is measuring the stock market versus the number of people working:
While the stock market inches closer to peak levels, the employment numbers are four million below the peak reached when the recession started. What many companies have done is slashed costs and have squeezed more out of employees. This has been reflected in increased productivity figures. Yet this is not showing up in household incomes as demonstrated by wages. Don’t take my word for it. Listen to what those that are near to the stock market machine are saying:
“1) The middle class is dead. A few weeks ago I visited a friend of mine who manages a trillion dollars. No joke. A trillion. If I told you the name of the family he worked for you would say, “they have a trillion? Really?” But that’s what happens when ten million dollars compounds at 2% over 200 years.
He said, “look out the windows”. We looked out at all the office buildings around us. “What do you see?” he said. “I don’t know.” “They’re empty! All the cubicles are empty. The middle class is being hollowed out.” And I took a closer look. Entire floors were dark. Or there were floors with one or two cubicles but the rest empty. “It’s all outsourced or technology has taken over for the paper shufflers,” he said.
“Not all the news is bad,” he said. “More people entered the upper class than ever last year.” But, he said, more people are temp staffers than ever.
And that’s the new paradigm. The middle class has died. The American Dream never really existed. It was a marketing scam.”
Not exactly a positive sign for the middle class. What is also surprising is with all the debt inspired solutions, stock volatility is at multi-year lows:
In other words those investing into the stock market are playing this as if all the issues in the economy were completely resolved. Retail investors have been yanking money out of the stock market however:
This trend from equities to fixed incomes is poised to continue deep into 2013:
It is estimated that retail investors will be moving out of funds to the tune of $475 billion this year. Big players will make up for the lag however. This is simply another sign of the hollowing out of the middle. Yet the market is not reflecting any volatility with current players. However this is not necessarily a sign that the underlying fundamentals of the economy are good. We have an unprecedented number of people working part-time gigs or contract positions in this modern day low wage capitalist system. The stock market is largely a shell game for most of the public.
For most Americans, home is where the wealth is:
Even with the run up in real estate prices in 2012, home prices are still down by over 30 percent from their recent peaks. Keep in mind much of this is happening because of very high leverage being injected into the mortgage markets by the Federal Reserve, not income growth. So the move up in prices is merely a reflection of more added leverage. Large investment banks are making good money once again thanks to the Fed setting up a system of socializing losses and privatizing gains. The stock market is a giant sideshow for most Americans and many are simply pulling their money out.