Is college worth the money and debt? The cost of college has increased by 11x since 1980 while inflation overall has increased by 3x. Diluting education with for-profits. and saddling millions with debt.
- 6 Comment
Is a college degree worth it? Since the debt bubble burst spectacularly in 2007 many more prospective students are questioning the worth of a college degree. For so many decades it was simply taken at face value that getting a college degree, any college degree would be worth it. Slowly this perception has morphed when annual tuition is running at $20,000 or more at for-profit institutions and $50,000 for private institutions. More to the point, most of the recent educational growth has been financed with large wallet crushing student loans. This financing of the college dream is turning out story after gut-wrenching story of college education nightmares. When a college education becomes this expensive it is important that potential students become savvy consumers. The financial sector certainly isn’t going to offer any advice on navigating the minefield of higher education since they largely have their greedy hands on this sector of the economy as well.
The soaring cost of college
In hindsight everyone seems to now agree that the housing bubble was rather obvious to spot since it far outstripped every measure of inflation and even rose while incomes fell. You would think this lesson would be learned but the cost of a college education is much deeper into bubble territory even beyond the metrics of the housing market at its peak:
Source: Cluster Stock
While housing at the peak rose by a factor of 4 (400 on the chart) college tuition has soared by a factor of 10 (it hasn’t stopped going up so it is now likely up in the 11x or 12x range). It is a downright startling figure especially when the incomes of recent college graduates has gone in the complete opposite direction:
Source: BusinessWeek
Since 2000 real earnings for college graduates has fallen while tuition costs continue to soar and put students into further student loan debt. I was hearing a few stories about states with record applicants to public universities yet with state budgets hurting, these schools are unable to meet the demand. So students are left with the option of $50,000 a year for private institutions or going to for-profits that are a step above paper mills. For this reason we have seen a giant increase in for-profit enrollments:
Source: Senator Harkin
For-profits have tripled their growth since 2000 which I also believe has diluted the earnings potential of the overall college pool and has also saddled many students with incredible amounts of debt. We are set to surpass the $1 trillion mark in student debt in 2012. The recent recovery has been a low-wage employment recovery so many recent graduates are coming out with heavy debt burdens and finding employment opportunities that pay much less:
Source: NLEP
We have lost a stunning 5,000,000+ mid-wage to high-wage jobs and have only added 1,000,000 since the recovery started way back in the summer of 2009. Yet the pool of graduates continues to grow. Another startling fact is many state schools are seeing peek applications even though high school graduation trends show a smaller cohort. Why? You have many people going back to school trying to retool especially after losing a job. Yet going to a for-profit school for gaming, art, or some other career path may prove to be a very expensive realization that not all college degrees are created equal. In many instances students would be better set if they went to a 2-year college or a trade school to pick-up the education they require.
“The difference of course is that state schools do not market to you. You have to go to them. The for-profits spend more money on marketing than they do on instruction. That should tell you where their priorities sit.”
Most of the for-profits are owned by large financial institutions that had their hand in this economic meltdown we are living through:
So a lot of the dilution in educational quality has come at the hands of these institutions. However, you also have private institutions outside of the top-tier that are heavily marketing and recruiting to pull students into their expensive four year traps. There are a few rules you should follow if you are not sure how much debt you should take on when pursuing a college education:
-First, your maximum student loan debt should not pass your expected annual salary after college.
-Second, you should do your own market analysis of the field you are going into. Many of these schools promise unrealistic placement data.
-Third, if unsure, look at 2-year state schools and transferring to a state 4-year institution. Because of budget constraints and the above factors, state schools have gotten more competitive because people realize the other options are either too expensive or simply not worth it.
-Finally, If you really want to go to a private institution, consider a state school first and transferring into a graduate degree later.
The net worth gap between younger and older Americans is already large enough and doesn’t need to be bigger with the saddling of student debt:
Source: CNN Money
To expect a 17 or 18 year old to understand this is hard to see but parents need to step it up but with the average per worker salary being $25,000 it is doubtful many parents have the resources to run an in-depth market analysis when it comes to choosing the right school or program. As usual do your own due diligence and don’t be fooled by the notion that all colleges are created equal and that college is priceless. At these cost levels, you better believe that there is a significant price.
If you enjoyed this post click here to subscribe to a complete feed and stay up to date with today’s challenging market!
6 Comments on this post
Trackbacks
-
mile said:
and 27 percent being entangled in the for profit prision industry with the creation of more nd more rules and kickbacks to make this possible, how does “schooling” get to be different.?
January 5th, 2012 at 2:26 pm -
DivaEl said:
Part of the reason for the wealth gap is that the geezers have been hell bent on ensuring that they continue to receive their overly generous Social Security and Medicare benefits at the expense of young people who have to foot the bill but can never expect to receive those benefits in turn when they get old. The geezers have been leeching off the young to expand their share of the pie for decades. This kind of intergenerational theft would unconscionable in a truly just society.
January 6th, 2012 at 7:34 am -
Bud Wood said:
Whether college education is worthwhile is the education received and the cost of that education. My education in electrical engineering and my sons’ educations in physics, EE and Chem Engrg were very worthwhile and all of us came out with no debt.
At this point, however, one needs to seriously weight the benefits. In most cases, there are few benefits for things like gender studies, race relations and political “science”. In fact, some such courses only engender disappointment at best and general disgust with our system (which has provided material benefits far beyond those of other political systems). Then some students get a bill for that – - talk about adding insult to injury!
No doubt about it. The “ivory towers” will be falling down. In most cases,young people need to stay clear and go about they own ways, aided by realistic expectations and reasonable parental guidance if that is possible.
January 6th, 2012 at 10:40 am -
Angela said:
Seems like such common sense “first thing I’d think of” advice here, but then again I wasn’t conned into buying a huge McMansion on a balloon interest rate with 0% down on a $50,000 a year salary either. I wonder where people’s minds are these days…
January 7th, 2012 at 9:10 am -
Joe Torrea said:
Hey DivaEl
Understand that Social Security is not a free gift to the geezers. Social Security use to be called Social Security Insurance, does SSI ring a bell. It was and still is a mandatory insurance policy paid by the worker and the employer. I as a geezer will never ever collect all of the money I paid into it. In addition most of my friends, hundreds of them are long dead before even collecting a single social security check. Social Security is not an entitlement but a insurance policy that the geezers were forced to pay into wheather we wanted it or not. where all the money that was payed into it went is the question. Since only 12% of the people live long enough to collect a single check and many of them collect only a few checks before dropping dead from supporting their lazy children who are still living at home at 18 years of age. I moved out of my parents home at 16 and supported myself ever since and never borrowed a single cent from my parents. Give me my God damn Social Security check, I had to pay for the stupid insurance that I didn’t want. Now give me my stupid insurance that I paid the last 50 years for.January 8th, 2012 at 5:07 am -
Bernadette Bay O'Shaughnessy said:
I am surprised by the number of college kids who insist on studying things like art, music, political science,etc. These will get you nowhere! Ditto for teaching! The so-called ‘teacher shortage’ is pure bunkum. Study something medical or technical and do your art ‘thing’ on the side! Grandma Moses never took an art course and Hemingway never went to college! Either you have talent or you don’t. Find a field in high demand, get into it as quickly as you can, then do the rest later. I am a published author(42 books so far) with 15+ years working as a newspaper/magazine reporter/writer. My parents were afraid that journalism was ‘precarious’ and insisted I take a med lab tech course(which I did!) Thankfully, between the 2 I have always found employment. Given a shortage of funds, I would have gone for the lab tech training first and taken writing courses on the side.
January 9th, 2012 at 9:25 pm
